6
The respondent is a 20 year old person from Sudan. On the 30th of March 2026 the respondent and three other people started to walk to Croatia after already having experienced several pushbacks. He reports that they started from the Lipa temporary reception center and it took them one day to get to the border. After crossing the border the group of four continued walking for three more days in Croatia before the Croatian police apprehended them.
Lipa camp, where the respondent and the group departed from.
On the fourth day of their journey the group met the Croatian police. The respondent described them as wearing dark blue or black uniforms [this description could match the description of either the regular Croatian police, border police or special intervention police] and heading towards them in a police-van. Two police officers showed their guns at sight and told the group to stop. Those police officers called for reinforcement and another van showed up with three more police officers. They had the same uniforms but wore masks that hid their faces. The officers then took away the phones of the group, beat them with their hands and batons and put them in handcuffs. After that the police officers pushed the group of four into the second van and drove close to the border to a river. They pushed the group out of the van and beat them again with hands and batons. After that they told the group that they should go back from here to where they came from. They forced them to go through the cold river and told them to not turn around. The police officers watched them crossing the river and shouted again that they should not come back.
After crossing the river the group didn’t have clothes to change and had to keep their wet and cold clothes on although it was cold at that time, especially during the night. They slept one night on the Bosnian side close to the river. On the next day two of the group went to a close village while the other two waited because they were too exhausted. The two people that reached the village took a taxi to pick up the other two and then drove back to the Lipa temporary reception center.

legal analysis

Beating is an act of physical violence that violates Art. 3 ECHR; Art. 4 EU Charter; Art. 5 UDHR; Art. 7 ICCPR. Pushbacks violate non-refoulement and prohibition of collective expulsion. See Art. 33 Refugee Convention; Art. 3 ECHR; Prot.4 Art.4 ECHR; Art.19 EU Charter. The exposure to extreme temperatures like the cold river and having no clothes to change afterwards can cause serious suffering and health risks and is a violation of Art. 3 ECHR; Art. 4 EU Charter; Art. 7 ICCPR. The theft of personal belongings violates property right according to Prot.1 Art.1 ECHR; Art.17 EU Charter; Art.3 ECHR.