This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.
“They forced us to get naked, searched us and beat us up”

legal analysis
Children, especially unaccompanied and separated migrant children, are especially vulnerable and at risk of being abused or exploited (ECtHR, S.F. and Others v. Bulgaria, App no. 8138/16, 2017, § 79). The rights of minors are thus additionally safeguarded by the Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC) as well as by specific articles of the treaties (e.g. Art. 24 EUCFR). The actions taken by the authorities, including threats of deportation, coercive tactics and failure to communicate effectively with the minors, violate several of those articles. While the “best interest of the child” is not defined in the CRC, the UN Committee on the Rights of the child has established a framework in its general comment no. 14: a decision that affects a child has to, in the decision-making process, assess the possible positive or negative impact of that decision on the child. The state has to pay primary consideration to the best interest of the child in all matters concerning children – administrative, legal, social etc. (see also Art. 24 EUCFR and e.g. ECtHR, Rahimi v. Greece, App no. 8687/08, 2011, § 108). Beating is a physical assault that constitutes inhuman and degrading treatment, to use this force is never justified in migration control. Art. 3 ECHR; Art. 4 EU Charter; Art. 5 UDHR; Art. 7 ICCPR The practice of pushbacks, as described by the respondent, constitutes a violation of the prohibition of collective expulsion and the fundamental rights to asylum, protection from refoulement, and human dignity (Art. 14 UDHR; Art. 33(1) Refugee Convention; Art. 3 ECHR; Art. 4 Protocol No. 4 ECHR; Art. 18, 19, and 47 EUCFR). Pushbacks—where individuals are summarily expelled without an individual assessment of their protection needs or access to asylum procedures—are in breach of the principle of non-refoulement, which prohibits returning a person to a country where they may face serious harm. The European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) has repeatedly affirmed that collective expulsions without proper procedural safeguards are unlawful, regardless of the migration status of the individuals concerned (e.g., ECtHR, Hirsi Jamaa and Others v. Italy [GC], App no. 27765/09, 2012, §§ 185-186). The use of dog attacks constitutes cruel and inhuman treatment that can cause severe physical and psychological harm. Art. 3 ECHR; Art. 4 EU Charter; Art. 5 UDHR; Art. 7 ICCPR Forced nudity is a degrading treatment that may constitute sexual violence or torture. Art. 3 ECHR; Art. 4 EU Charter; Art. 17 ICCPR; Art. 12 UDHR Threats, intimidation and humiliation cause severe psychological suffering. Art. 3 ECHR; Art. 4 EU Charter; Art. 7 ICCPR The unlawful confiscation of phones and money violates the property rights. Prot.1 Art.1 ECHR; Art.17 EU Charter; Art.3 ECHR