9
The group consisted of 6 Persons from Sudan, including two minors aged 17. They set off on 25 April, travelling on foot through the mountains toward the border. For four days, they walked through the snow. On the 5th day the 17 year old respondent fell over a hill and got injured. Due to his pain he wasn’t able to walk anymore, so he called a number for help. They told him to wait for an ambulance that should arrive after one hour, but the ambulance never came. The rest of the group decided to keep going, he and his brother kept waiting. After 5 hours there was still no ambulance coming but a black jeep appeared. Inside the jeep were 4 police officers.
The police officers took them and drove them approximately 60km , then they dropped them off and another car came. The other car was a white car with 2 police officers and a dog inside. They drove them another 30mins and then stopped. The officers ordered them to get out of the car, forced them to get naked, searched them, and beat them up, even though the respondent was already injured. They took their phones and all of their money. The police then told them to go in a certain direction, pointing towards a river. Realising that they were expected to cross it, the two brothers tried to explain that they don’t know how to swim and could not cross the river safely. But the police wouldn’t listen to them; when they continued to try to talk to the police, they set the dog on them. So they ran into the river.
After they luckily crossed the river they walked around 3km to a village where people found them. They gave them some food and called a taxi to bring them back to Lipa Camp.
Lipa Camp

legal analysis

Children, especially unaccompanied and separated migrant children, are especially vulnerable and at risk of being abused or exploited (ECtHR, S.F. and Others v. Bulgaria, App no. 8138/16, 2017, § 79). The rights of minors are thus additionally safeguarded by the Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC) as well as by specific articles of the treaties (e.g. Art. 24 EUCFR). The actions taken by the authorities, including threats of deportation, coercive tactics and failure to communicate effectively with the minors, violate several of those articles. While the “best interest of the child” is not defined in the CRC, the UN Committee on the Rights of the child has established a framework in its general comment no. 14: a decision that affects a child has to, in the decision-making process, assess the possible positive or negative impact of that decision on the child. The state has to pay primary consideration to the best interest of the child in all matters concerning children – administrative, legal, social etc. (see also Art. 24 EUCFR and e.g. ECtHR, Rahimi v. Greece, App no. 8687/08, 2011, § 108). Beating is a physical assault that constitutes inhuman and degrading treatment, to use this force is never justified in migration control. Art. 3 ECHR; Art. 4 EU Charter; Art. 5 UDHR; Art. 7 ICCPR The practice of pushbacks, as described by the respondent, constitutes a violation of the prohibition of collective expulsion and the fundamental rights to asylum, protection from refoulement, and human dignity (Art. 14 UDHR; Art. 33(1) Refugee Convention; Art. 3 ECHR; Art. 4 Protocol No. 4 ECHR; Art. 18, 19, and 47 EUCFR). Pushbacks—where individuals are summarily expelled without an individual assessment of their protection needs or access to asylum procedures—are in breach of the principle of non-refoulement, which prohibits returning a person to a country where they may face serious harm. The European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) has repeatedly affirmed that collective expulsions without proper procedural safeguards are unlawful, regardless of the migration status of the individuals concerned (e.g., ECtHR, Hirsi Jamaa and Others v. Italy [GC], App no. 27765/09, 2012, §§ 185-186). The use of dog attacks constitutes cruel and inhuman treatment that can cause severe physical and psychological harm. Art. 3 ECHR; Art. 4 EU Charter; Art. 5 UDHR; Art. 7 ICCPR Forced nudity is a degrading treatment that may constitute sexual violence or torture. Art. 3 ECHR; Art. 4 EU Charter; Art. 17 ICCPR; Art. 12 UDHR Threats, intimidation and humiliation cause severe psychological suffering. Art. 3 ECHR; Art. 4 EU Charter; Art. 7 ICCPR The unlawful confiscation of phones and money violates the property rights. Prot.1 Art.1 ECHR; Art.17 EU Charter; Art.3 ECHR